16 Comments
Nov 11, 2022Liked by Dana Miranda

I agree with you that extreme budgeting can result in an unhealthy money psychology.

FiRE is broad tent, and it seems most of your criticism is specific to a limited swath, "fast lean FIRE" (I added fast as a contrast to slow but "lean FIRE" is a common term).

"Slow FIRE" or "slow fat FIRE" doesn't have the same budget fixation. In fact, check out Paula Pant's concept of the "anti-budget" (allocation of savings/investing off the top and don't budget the rest). I'd argue that fat, or for some people, even normal (non-lean) FIRE expressly allows not focusing on budget more than lack of FI, both vefore and after achieving FI, since it breaks the connection between a paycheck and living expenses, allowing for a reduction in focus on money. If you listen to people who have achieved FI, many say that they hardly think about money after having achieved FI.

Expand full comment
Nov 3, 2022Liked by Dana Miranda

Slow FI sounds like a much healthier approach. My problem with FIRE is twofold. First, it smacks of privilege, as you point out. Second, tomorow is not guaranteed to any of us. While I’m a big believer in saving for the future, it can’t be at the expense of enjoying the life you have today.

Expand full comment
Oct 19, 2022Liked by Dana Miranda

I think we ended working toward Slow FI before there was a term for it. I also feel like so much of stuff about FI is written by young men without kids--never very pertinent to my experience so I’m just not interested.

Expand full comment
Oct 19, 2022Liked by Dana Miranda

Rest is a book by Alex Soojung-Kim Pang where he dissects an average 4 hour work day as the most “optimal” with scientific research... financial independence should have a spirit of freedom with it. That’s what I desire to contribute and feel free at the same time.

Expand full comment

Consistent with what you've written: Retire at 35. What meaningful work are you going to engage in for the next 50 years?

Expand full comment